Thursday, August 2, 2007

08/02 - Opinion: READERS WRITE: Responses to "Let Jekyll stay incentive-free, affordable," @issue, July 27

By Mike Powers, Brenda K. Layne, Von Diaz, Deirdra Schmandt Alexander
For the Journal-Constitution
Published on: 08/02/07
Jekyll Island: Responses to "Let Jekyll stay incentive-free, affordable," @issue, July 27

All deserve to enjoy jewel

It is a pleasant surprise to hear Edward Boshears speak openly about the behind-the-scenes wheeling and dealing orchestrated by the rest of the Jekyll Island State Park Authority. How can the JIA justify a $10 million tax break for the developer while they claim the authority lacks funds to maintain or improve existing features on the island?

Georgia's citizens need to wake up and realize plans are under way to destroy the limited remaining natural beauty of Jekyll Island in order to build another playground for the select few wealthiest of citizens. Every Georgia citizen needs to demand that the JIA live up to its charter and make plans for Jekyll Island that are affordable for the majority of our citizens.

The island belongs to all of us, not just the select few developers and politicians greedily drooling over each parcel of land. I am all for upgrading and maintaining existing properties to attract visitors. Just make sure the affordability index covers those families earning $30,000 to $50,000, not just the $100,000 and up families.

MIKE POWERS, Hiram

Preserve its beauty

Thank heavens for Jekyll Island State Park Authority Board member Edward Boshears, who expresses the feeling of the vast majority of Georgians. Modern hotels are no substitute for nature's beauty. The coastline already has a plethora of costly hotels. Let's not destroy one of the last unspoiled islands in our state.

BRENDA K. LAYNE, Gainesville

08/01 - Not such a 'sweet' deal

Brunswick News
Date August 01, 2007
Section(s) Letters


I am writing in response to the advertisement written by Jekyll Island Authority Chair Ben Porter, which was published first as an editorial in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

What Ben Porter does not say in his opinion piece is that those few island residents who resist any and all efforts to improve guest accommodations and increase visitation represent the Initiative to Protect Jekyll Island, a grassroots organization of 5,000 members throughout North America dedicated to soliciting and communicating the will of the people on this issue.

What Porter does not say is that he has received over 100 pages of comments from Jekyll Island visitors stating that Jekyll Island must be kept affordable to people of average means.

What Porter does not say is that Trammel Crow's properties will more than double current room rates on those sites.

Sweetheart deals do not benefit the people of Georgia, nor do they justify our trust, nor do they befit the appointed stewards of Georgia's economic and natural resources.

Dory Ingram

Atlanta

It's about time some improvements are made

After 30 years of neglect, it sounds like something is finally being done about Jekyll Island.

My family won't return until we see some improvements.

I consider myself a person of modest income, but even I realize that it will take some upscale development to pay for all the infrastructure needs on the island.

I only hope the media and malcontents on the Jekyll Island Authority will not run off investors in the process.

Mindy Anderson

Glenwood

It's Jekyll residents who are getting the deal

As a member of the committee that debated legislation to extend the state lease to the Jekyll Island Authority, I am well aware of the sweetheart deals on Jekyll Island.

It is the 600-plus residents who have the sweetheart deal. Imagine having a home valued at $500,000 or more that you enjoy exclusively through 2049, yet you only pay the authority $300 per year for real estate.

Maybe our committee can go back next year and evaluate all of the current residential leases and base them on market rate or otherwise rent them to the general public.

Even better, if the residents want price controls on Jekyll, perhaps they should agree to sell their homes for less than market value.

That way, beach-front living would be even more affordable to the average Georgian.

These are the same residents that came to committee meetings and supported the extension of the lease and asked for more money on improvements to the island, but don't want to allow the developments that will fund the improvements.

And, finally, to hear board member Ed Boshears complain about the lease agreement after voting "yes" reminds me of John Kerry's political epitaph: "I voted for it before I voted against it."

I am pleased to see that Gov. Sonny Perdue chose a leader in Chairman Ben Porter to return the island to its heyday.

Rep. Steven Davis, R-McDonough

Member of State Institutions and Properties Committee

Wednesday, August 1, 2007

08/01 - Jekyll resident files complaint with AG

Wed, Aug 1, 2007
By MARY STARR
The Brunswick News

A Jekyll Island resident is asking the Georgia Attorney General's Office to investigate claims of wrongdoing on the Jekyll Island Authority Board of Directors.

Joe Iannicelli, an island resident and former member of the Glynn County Board of Education, alleges the Jekyll board of directors kept secret its plan to give a $10 million rent abatement to a developer.

"(Board chair Ben) Porter never announced what they were giving Trammell Crow," Iannicelli said of the developer hired to renovate the Buccaneer Hotel into a $90 million hotel/condominium complex.

"And they never reported the details, either in the committee meeting or the open meeting."

The deal was finalized at the board's July 9 meeting.

Iannicelli also said he has been unable to obtain copies of the financial projections produced by Jekyll Island Authority staff that illustrate the rent abatement package with Trammell Crow.

"They've said I can look at them," he said. "But they have refused to provide me with copies."

Iannicelli originally filed his complaint that the board violated Georgia's Open Meetings Act, which requires public business to be conducted in an open manner, with the State Ethics Commission.

The ethics commission rejected Iannicelli's complaint, saying it investigates violations solely involving elected officials, lobbyists and vendors that do business with the state.

Political appointees, such as the members of the Jekyll Island board, are not within its purview.

"They blew it (the complaint) off," Iannicelli said. "They said they had no jurisdiction."

That led him to the attorney general's office.

"They're going to have a hard time saying they don't have jurisdiction," Iannicelli said.

The deal also has caused controversy among members of the board of directors.

Board member Ed Boshears, who lives on St. Simons Island, voted for the abatement, but since has blasted it and his fellow board members by calling it a plan to eliminate affordable accommodations on Jekyll Island.

Bert Brantley, a spokesperson for Gov. Sonny Perdue, previously has said the governor favors a variety of lodging choices on the state-owned island.

Multiple attempts to contact Porter to respond to criticisms have proved unsuccessful.

Since Boshears leveled his charges, Porter addressed a letter to the community criticizing his colleague and lauding the benefits the Trammell Crow deal will bring to Georgia, Glynn County and Jekyll Island.

Tuesday, July 31, 2007

07/31 - Jekyll issues approaching boiling point

Tue, Jul 31, 2007
By MARY STARR
The Brunswick News

It may be fitting that as the height of hurricane season approaches, a storm is brewing on Jekyll Island.

Not only are members of the Jekyll Island Authority Board of Directors at odds with one of their own, but some residents are unhappy with leadership of the board and how deals are being made.

The issues are coming to a head, and some citizens and board members have goals in common while on other issues they are miles apart.

They include:
* The deal between the Jekyll Island Authority and the developer of a new hotel.
* The composition of the authority's board.

Development

The aging Buccaneer Hotel at Jekyll Island's southern beach area is to be demolished this fall and replaced with a $90 million, 540-room hotel-condominium complex.

The Jekyll Island Authority Board of Directors has given developer Trammell Crow a $10 million rent abatement package that would be spread over the first 10 years of the life of the hotel.

Board member Ed Boshears voted for the abatement, but since has blasted it and his fellow board members by calling it a plan to eliminate affordable accommodations on Jekyll Island.

Tise Eyler, a former president of the Jekyll Island Citizen's Association, said no one opposes old hotels being torn down and rebuilt.

He said Boshears merely exercised his democratic duty to speak out. "Isn't this what our democracy expects?" Eyler asked. "Ed Boshears ... has constantly reminded the JIA Board that the state charter creating Jekyll wanted to preserve a beachfront experience to many who could not afford the increasing cost of vacationing at other beach locations."

Ben Porter of Macon, chair of the Jekyll Island Authority Board of Directors, has called Boshears, who lives on St. Simons Island, a "disgruntled, publicity-seeking board member" because of his criticism of the abatement package.

In an open letter to the community, Porter said the new hotel will pay more than $15 million in tax and rent revenue over a 15-year period. He said the state will collect an additional $13.3 million in sales tax revenue over that period and Glynn County will receive an additional $10 million in sales tax and $10.9 million in property tax.

But David Egan, who oversees the citizen's group Initiative to Protect Jekyll Island, said the board's logic doesn't add up.

"We have a highly attractive beachfront," Egan said. "It doesn't make sense to offer an incentive."

Egan said Porter's claims that the planned hotel will generate $14 million more than the existing Buccaneer Hotel is not news.

"It should generate more," Egan said. "It will be triple the size and charge double the rates."

Egan said the point is not how much more revenue the new hotel will generate, but how the authority – rather than a developer – could have benefited from that money.

Board composition

Egan wants Gov. Sonny Perdue, who appoints the members of the Jekyll Island Authority board, to take a long look at the group's membership.

"If there are board members who are acting contrary to Jekyll's affordability mandate and who are restricting public commentary on this issue and ignoring visitor input when it is given to them, then they should be advised to alter their course or step down from the board," Egan said.

Bert Brantley, a Perdue spokesperson, said the governor is watching developments and supports Jekyll's board of directors.

"The governor has confidence in the people who are on the board because of their combined record of public service," Brantley said.

But, he added, the governor is always receptive to public input and has no preconceived notions as to what Jekyll Island should look like.

"He wants what is best for Jekyll Island and the people of Georgia," Brantley said.

Monday, July 30, 2007

07/30 - ajc Q&A

ajc > Q&A ON THE NEWS
Published on: 07/30/07


Q: A recent editorial page article on Jekyll Island mentioned "600 island residents." Do these people pay any kind of rent or fees and to whom?

STEVE DOSTER, Athens

A: Jekyll Island, the 7.5-mile barrier island off Georgia's southern coast, is owned by the state and earns money from annual land leases paid by the island's 623 homeowners, eight hotels, 19 shops and 14 restaurants.

Jekyll's 1,000 year-round residents, retirees mostly, pay their rent to the Jekyll Island Authority, whose members are appointed by the governor.

Residents pay about $265 annually per lot, and they also pay county property taxes.

Staff researcher Sharon Gaus contributed to this column.

Do you have a question about the news? Our news researchers will try to get an answer. Call 404-222-2002 or e-mail q&a@ajc.com (include your name and city). Sorry, individual responses are not possible.

07/30 - Jekyll's board hurling insults

Jekyll's board hurling insults
Mon, Jul 30, 2007
By MARY STARR
The Brunswick News

The future of Jekyll Island has been fought over in the halls and chambers of the Georgia General Assembly and now the battle is being waged among members of the board of the Jekyll Island Authority.
At the heart of the matter is a $10 million tax abatement package awarded to Trammell Crow, developers of a proposed $90 million, 540-room hotel-condominium complex with meeting space, restaurants and a spa to replace the current Buccaneer Hotel.

Members of the authority's board who strongly favor the incentive package accuse the one member who thinks it is a bad idea, Ed Boshears, of being a malcontent.
In an open letter to the community Friday, Ben G. Porter, chair of the authority board, refers to Boshears as a "disgruntled, publicity-seeking board member" because of his recent criticism of the tax abatement package. Other board members signing the letter included Steve Croy, Mike Hodges, Samuel B. Kellett Jr., Becky Kelley, Bob Krueger and Sybil Lynn.

Boshears voted for the package but has since spoken out against it.
In a letter to The News, Boshears said he opposes what appears to be a plan to eliminate affordable accommodations on Jekyll Island, which is owned by the state.
Jekyll Island's state charter requires it to be affordable to average Georgians.

"When I raised the issue of keeping affordable hotels like the Days Inn on Jekyll, another developer on the board stated, 'We're not building any Section 8 housing over here,'" Boshears said in his letter.

Section 8 is subsidized housing for low-income families.

"And (the developer added), let them (sic) stay in the campground," Boshears said. "This is the kind of mentality I have to contend with on the Jekyll board."

Boshears refutes Porter's claim that the former Republican state senator is seeking publicity.

"What Mr. Porter is really unhappy about is that I will not conspire with him to conceal the true facts from the people of Georgia," Boshears added.

The letter by Porter and other authority board members states that because the new hotel will pay more than $15 million total in tax and rent revenue during a 15-year period than the current lease, it's a "win-win" for everyone involved.
The group also contends in the letter that the additional tax revenue collected by the state and Glynn County over the same period of time – estimated at about $23 million in sales and property tax revenue – makes the abatement package worthwhile.

Boshears says the numbers don't tell the whole story.

"They're trying to claim that because a lot more money will be coming in, the abatement doesn't exist," Boshears said. "How are we going to pay our bills for the next 12 years?"

Bryan Thompson, mayor of Brunswick, a city which benefits from jobs generated by Jekyll Island, says that any ongoing improvement will be an asset to Brunswick and to the entire area.

"I've always viewed Jekyll (Island) and St. Simons (Island) as advantageous to downtown Brunswick," Thompson said.
Thompson said that for the past five or six years, most people who vacation on Jekyll or St. Simons islands spend at least one day in Brunswick.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

07/29 - Jekyll developer incentive stirs mud

Jekyll developer incentive stirs mud

By Dan Chapman
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 07/29/07


Uproar over the Jekyll Island Authority's decision to grant a $10 million rent break to one of the nation's largest developers intensified last week as some state officials, government watchdogs and island residents called for the incentives to be rescinded and the board chairman to resign.

A resident filed a state ethics complaint against Chairman Ben Porter, claiming "serious malfeasance" in the awarding of incentives to Trammell Crow Co., the Texas developer planning a $90 million hotel and condo project along the state park's shoreline.
An authority board member called Porter "a liar" and asked that he step down. A state senator wants a legislative oversight committee to review the deal.

Critics also asked Gov. Sonny Perdue, who appoints board members, to investigate whether the rent break was justified and whether the board acted in the best interests of Georgia's residents.

While local and state governments routinely give incentives to spur development, critics question why Jekyll —- a state park/barrier island with some of the East Coast's most untrammeled beachfront property —- needs to entice developers with rent abatements.
Roughly $200 million in hotel redevelopment is planned.

"We didn't treat it as rent abatement, but as an incentive to get a major developer to get going as quickly as possible," Porter said Friday. "We are absolutely committed to having a full range of affordable facilities and accommodations on the island for all prices ranges and all economic levels of the citizens of Georgia."

Meanwhile, board members spent the week excoriating each other via e-mails and guest editorials in The Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
'Liars' or self-promotion

Ed Boshears, a board member and critic of fellow board members Porter and Steve Croy, both coastal developers, said the rent deal should be rescinded. He lambasted board members for misrepresenting the need for incentives.

"These people are the most shameless liars I have ever seen in my entire life," Boshears, a Brunswick attorney and former Republican state senator, said Wednesday. "They don't want Jekyll to [remain] as it has for the last 50 years —- a place for average people of this state to come and stay, go to conventions or bring children to the beach. They want to rebuild Jekyll as an upscale resort."

Porter said "he was disappointed in Mr. Boshears' actions." Croy didn't return phone calls seeking comment.

The hullabaloo revolves around $10 million in rent abatements for Trammell Crow and partners through 2020, according to an analysis by the authority's staff.

Trammell Crow plans to build a minimum 300-room hotel with 120 two-room condos, a restaurant and a spa on 9.7 oceanfront acres where the run-down Buccaneer Beach Resort now sits.

In addition, Trammell Crow and a handful of other developers are angling to be chosen the island's "master" development partner.

Preliminary plans highlight $3 billion in new hotels, condos, shops, restaurants and convention amenities.

The state bought Jekyll in 1947 and designated "a state park for the plain people of Georgia." By law, 65 percent of the island must remain undeveloped. Porter and other authority members say some future accommodations will remain affordable.

But state Sen. Jeff Chapman (R-Brunswick), whose district includes Jekyll, is troubled that the deal with Trammell Crow does not include any language guaranteeing "moderately priced" rooms. A Trammell Crow official has said rooms during the summer would run $250 a night.

"The question remains, why did they have to give the $10 million incentive?" asked Chapman, who wants the island's legislative oversight committee to review the deal. "The location is very attractive to everyone who enjoys a visit to the ocean. It's not a remote location. It's close to a major interstate. I imagine that people would be very interested in having the opportunity to place a hotel there."

An AJC article on July 23 describing what Boshears labeled a "sweetheart deal" prompted a flurry of angry e-mails and name-calling among board members.

Croy sent a note Monday to all board members castigating Boshears for "shameless self-promotion."

Croy also said Boshears "distorts the truth for nothing more than pushing forward a personal agenda at the expense of the other members of this board."

On Wednesday, Porter penned an op-ed that said only "one disgruntled, publicity-seeking board member and a few island residents" oppose redevelopment of Jekyll. All board members, except Boshears, approved the column, Porter said.

On Friday, Boshears responded in an AJC op-ed of his own: "What Porter is really unhappy about is that I will not conspire with him to conceal the true facts from the people of Georgia."
Ethics complaint

The State Ethics Commission received a complaint Friday from island resident Joe Iannicelli claiming a "systematic series of ethical violations" by Porter.

Porter "rammed through a proposal to grant an undisclosed amount of concessions" to Trammell Crow," wrote Iannicelli, a former Glynn County school board chairman. "This extraordinary giveaway of Jekyll Island revenues . . . suggests serious malfeasance on the part of Mr. Ben Porter."

Rick Thompson, executive secretary of the State Ethics Commission, said his agency will determine this week whether the complaint will be investigated.

Most Jekyll board members didn't learn of the Trammell Crow deal until the morning of June 18 when they were asked to vote on it. The board unanimously approved the deal, including the $10 million incentives package.

Porter, in his op-ed piece, said the authority will reap $15.6 million more in revenues from Trammell Crow's project than it would if the Buccanneer were to continue operating the next 15 years.

Critics, however, say the comparison is not relevant because nobody expects the Buccanneer to remain open.
Boshears and another board member, after reading the Project Development Agreement between the Jekyll Island Authority and

Trammell Crow the afternoon of June 18, complained about the incentives and the lack of time to review the deal before the vote.

"I sincerely apologize for rushing this decision and assure you that I will make an effort to avoid this kind of problem in the future," Porter wrote board members June 28.

Neill Herring, a lobbyist for Sierra Club of Georgia, said Porter shouldn't get another opportunity.

"He should resign," Herring said. "He's obviously unqualified to run that authority. The idea that a motel operator for a beachfront motel needs a subsidy is absurd."

Herring, Boshears, Iannicelli, Chapman, the government watchdog Common Cause Georgia and others want the governor to review the authority's actions.

"If the governor were really on top of this issue he would not be too happy that his name and his credibility are associated with a board behaving the way this one is," said David Egan, co-director of the nonprofit Initiative to Protect Jekyll Island.

Perdue, in a statement Thursday, expressed "confidence" in Porter.
"Any kind of economic incentive to encourage development should be weighed carefully, on a case-by-case basis," Perdue added. "I will continue to review additional details of this agreement to see the business case for granting inducements."